Manhattan Pizzeria

About

Pizza

Price Range : Under $10 ($)

  • star
    Yelp rating
    4.5 stars

Location

Adress: 6225 W 56th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254

Phone: (317) 552-2141

Work Hours

Mon 10:30 am-9:00 pm
Tue 10:30 am-9:00 pm
Wed 10:30 am-9:00 pm
Thu 10:30 am-10:00 pm
Fri 10:30 am-10:00 pm
Sat 10:30 am-10:00 pm
Sun

Business info

  • turned_in_not
    Health Score
    99 out of 100
  • list_alt
    Takes Reservations
    No
  • directions_car
    Delivery
    Yes
  • move_to_inbox
    Take-out
    Yes
  • credit_card
    Accepts Credit Cards
    Yes
  • thumb_up
    Good For
    Lunch
  • local_parking
    Parking
    Private Lot
  • accessibility
    Good for Kids
    Yes
  • group
    Good for Groups
    Yes
  • insert_emoticon
    Ambience
    Classy
  • volume_up
    Noise Level
    Average
  • local_bar
    Alcohol
    No
  • transit_enterexit
    Outdoor Seating
    No
  • wifi
    Wi-Fi
    No
  • tv
    Has TV
    Yes
  • turned_in_not
    Waiter Service
    No

Reviews

  • Kara M.

    star star star star star 11 June 2026

    Reading some of the reviews of Manhattan Pizzeria I noticed some native New Yorkers said this pizza made them reminisce about the famous NY pizza they remember. If native New Yorkers give it a thumbs up than you know it's good. They had a lot of different options of pizzas to choose from. It's located right off of 56th close to Eagle Creek Park. It's in the same strip mall as The Boathouse Grill.

    I liked how the pizzas had a lot of toppings on them. No skimping! They have garlic knots, calzones, wings, and sausage and chicken rolls also. They have a pizza called grandma's pizza that's cut into squares and looks good! I will have to figure out what's on that and try it out! If you're looking for NY pizza go here!

  • Soraya G.

    star star star star star_border 21 May 2026

    Tasty pizza, friendly service, and with good prices.

    I could never tell you what's really NY style, never been, but I'll tell you the pizza is good! Crunchy crust, little oregano, and it's thin! They have a great lunch special during the week, you can buy by the slice or a whole pie, which are huge.

    The garlic knots were a little bland IMO, with just a ton of seasoning so I didn't care for them too much. But the standard ole cheese pizza never disappoints.

    Friendly staff, couple of younger kids running the show most of the time but it's very upbeat service and they're pretty attentive.

    Straightforward little unsuspecting pizza joint, if you don't get too caught up in the style!

  • Teresa M.

    star star star star star 20 May 2026

    I've been twice and both times were great!  They have one size 'pie' which is super size large.  We had it with sausage and mushroom... so good.

    Next time we decided to stop in because we knew they had pizza by the slice.  Super affordable and lots of selection.  I love the thin crust of this pizza l!!!

  • Marcy D.

    star star star star star 19 May 2026

    This is THE pizza place to go to if you live in the Eagle Creek area. Reliable service, good pizza and affordable! Def recommend the Garlic knots and grandma's pizza! You are able to dine in but we always make a carry out order and take it home.

  • Jaleesa J.

    star star star star star 18 May 2026

    Best pizza in the city. I, unfortunately, live down the street so I'm here at least three or four times a month. Is it healthy? No. Do I give a damn? Also no. ‍

People Recommend